16/11/2015 – A Civil Justice Council report says settling non-criminal cases of less than £25,000 online would reduce the expenses generated by a court.
A Civil Justice Council report says settling non-criminal cases of less than £25,000 online would reduce the expenses generated by a court. Principal author Prof Richard Susskind said eBay disputes were “minor”, like many civil court cases. Her Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service says it welcomes the report.
The proposed online dispute resolution scheme would be similar to the one used by online marketplace eBay to diagnose and resolve disputes. Online facilitators would be used to help parties reach an agreement, and if that failed, online judges would rule on cases without the need for courts to be booked or for the parties involved to appear in person to give evidence.
The report, from the Council’s online dispute resolution advisory group, suggests conducting a pilot, ahead of an anticipated full roll-out in 2017.
The BBC’s legal affairs correspondent Clive Coleman says the report is calling for a radical and fundamental change to the way courts deal with smaller claims.
’21st Century users’
It notes that the dispute resolution system run by eBay settles 60 million disputes between small traders every year. Prof Susskind said the model was “remarkable” and could be used in a similar way in the civil courts system which was “too costly, too complex and too slow”. Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, he said eBay disputes “are minor differences, but so are the very many differences in our civil courts system”.
Prof Susskind, who is IT adviser to the Lord Chief Justice, said the online court would have “a three-tier structure, and we expect most disputes to be resolved at the first two stages without a judge becoming involved”.
Under the proposals, tier one would be “dispute avoidance”, with interactive guides and information to help people understand their issues and identify the best way of resolving them. Tier two would be “dispute containment”, using “online facilitators” to help the parties reach agreement. Tier three would be “dispute resolution”, employing the use of judges to consider suitable cases online, largely on the basis of papers received electronically, but with an option of telephone hearings.
Prof Susskind said the system had the potential to resolve tens of thousands of cases every year and cost less for the parties involved and the taxpayer.
Lord Dyson, chairman of the Civil Justice Council, said in the foreword of the report that the area of online dispute resolution had “enormous potential”. Its aim was “to broaden access to justice and resolve disputes more easily, quickly and cheaply,” he said. “There will be a lot of work to be done, but I have no doubt that ODR will play an important role in the future of civil justice.”
‘Proper consultation’
The proposal for the creation of an online court comes five months after a senior judge called for courts to cut down on paper documents and move into the digital age. In September, Lady Justice Gloster, who sits in the Court of Appeal, said the amount of files used in trials was similar to when she started her legal career 40 years ago.
The Law Society welcomed the proposals but said “lessons should be learned about existing systems”. A spokesman said: “Proper consultation and proper investment would be essential. There has been a long history of underinvestment in court IT in England and Wales. A decade ago Lord Justice Woolf, in his report Access to Justice, identified the importance of better IT to the future of the civil justice system and in 2009 Lord Justice Jackson noted that the courts still did not have an IT system which was adequate for the delivery of civil justice at proportionate cost.”
Source: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-31483099
First Published: 16 February 2015
More Articles
Helping you find the light at the end of the tunnel thanks to our family solicitors in Amersham
Does a family solicitor in Amersham understand my pain?
Are you going through a messy divorce? Let us help you through the worst of it
How to avoid making a dogs dinner of choosing a company name
Another outstanding testimonial for the criminal department
Take the best way forward with family solicitors in Amersham you can trust
Licence and Liberty Saved
Betfred customer denied £1.7million prize due to 'glitch' takes case to court
How the written word could help your business
Sorry seems to be the hardest word for Katie Hopkins after defaming journalist on Twitter
Questions you should ask yourself when getting divorced
What according to an Amersham family solicitor are the most common reasons for family breakups?
How does a family solicitor in Amersham support my family during a divorce?
Continuing success for the CWD Criminal Department!
ANDY GREEN V BETFRED – COVERAGE BY THE DAILY MAIL, THE SUN, THE MIRROR, THE DAILY STAR, AND THE DAILY RECORD
The UK construction industry, insolvency, and the Labour Manifesto
ANDY GREEN V BETFRED- THE MEDIA COVERAGE CONTINUES WITH THE TIMES
Ways in which family solicitors in Amersham can assist with your divorce case
Blackjack gambler who won £1.7m with Betfred but never received a penny after firm blamed software glitch could be days away from getting his winnings at High Court
Guiding you through troubled waters thanks to our expert family solicitors in Amersham
CWD Company Update
Advice from a family solicitor in Amersham
Private Crime Team Success Continues in 2016
Corporate Insolvency - Ensuring the Appointment of Administrators is Valid
How family solicitors in Amersham can help you to protect your assets
Relieving financial pressure through an expert family solicitors in Amersham
Continuing success for CWD’s employment department
How family solicitors in Amersham can help with the issue of children during divorce
Sports law in the UK: A brief guide to the regulations that govern football
Divorce proceedings with a family solicitor in Amersham
Social media platforms, free speech, and UK law: Who is accountable?
DAVID V GOLIATH – CWD helps Lincolnshire man take on the might of Betfred
Another success for the CWD Criminal Department
A family solicitor in Amersham can advise on other ways to separate
Dos and don’ts of pre-nuptial agreements as suggested by our Amersham Family Solicitors
Customer Takes Betfred to High Court After Being Denied £1.7m Prize
Resolve your financial disputes professionally through reliable family solicitors in Amersham
Private Crime Team's Hard Work Pays Off Again
Announcing our new Private Crime Department
Putting the fun into fundraising in 2016
The legal side to ending a relationship when you cohabitate
Betfred gambler in High Court battle over £1.7m payout he never received
How family solicitors in Amersham can help you
Family solicitor attributes and what to look for
Finding a Family Solicitor in Amersham who is right for you
Coyle White Devine defeat Betfred in High Court Battle
Looking for a reliable solicitor firm in Amersham? Reasons to choose Coyle White Devine
Have you been a victim of domestic abuse? Ways to find the best solicitor to represent you
And they’re off! Betfred sued by £1.7m ‘winner’
Single dad refused £1.7 million Betfred payout over 'glitch' takes bookies to court
ANDY GREEN V BETFRED (DAVID VS GOLAITH) – MORE MEDIA COVERAGE FROM THE BBC
What does a family solicitor in Amersham do?
Case of Betfred refusing £1.7m payment to customer going to summary judgment in October
Need help with child custody? How our solicitors at Coyle White Devine can help you
Tips on how to keep your divorce civil and non-confrontational
Missed out on a prenuptial agreement? Coyle White Devine’s guide to postnuptial agreements
Announcement from Peter Coyle
Reach an amicable divorce using family solicitors Amersham
Keeping your head above water thanks to our quality family solicitors in Amersham
Double the Success for the Private Crime Team as CPS Squeezed into Discontinuing
Recent Developments in Employment Law
VW emissions scandal widens to include Porsche claims
Divorces and financial settlements How Coyle White Devine can help you with negotiations and resolution
The legal system is broken: Why are fees increasing but service and support decreasing?
Court of Appeal Rubs Salt in Stratstone's Wounds
Straightforward support by your family solicitors in Amersham
Questions you should ask a family solicitor before hiring them
Gambler's luck runs out
Family solicitors in Amersham - helping family disputes
CWD Law secures £1m+ win after 3-year battle with Paddy Power
Looking for family solicitors Amersham?
What does family law entail?
$2.2 Million Customer Dispute With Betfred Going to Summary Judgment
Guiding you towards an amicable solution with a trustworthy family solicitors in Amersham
Success for the CWD Criminal Department!
Need help with a postnuptial dispute? Coyle White Devine family solicitors can help
CWD Client Wins £1 Million Battle Against Paddy Power
The legal advantages of getting a prenuptial agreement at Coyle White Devine
Emphatic Success for Coyle White Devine's Private Crime Team
CWD Crime Team - Health and Safety Executive Interviews
Could mediation be your ticket to a hassle-free divorce?
Legal aid abolishment
Peter Coyle - Times Lawyer of the Week
ANDY GREEN V BETFRED – Peter Coyle’s Interview with The Gambling Insider
How do you get divorced?
What should I expect from Family Solicitors in Amersham?
ANDY GREEN v BETFRED – more media coverage